Navigating the Challenges of Supervising Professional Staff
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to Supervising Professional Staff
Supervising professional staff presents a unique set of challenges. Throughout my two decades in higher education and fraternity management, I encountered various professionals, from graduate students to seasoned individuals transitioning careers. Reflecting on my experiences, I realize that mastering effective supervision wasn't as intuitive as my interactions with students and volunteers. Some aspects of supervision came easily, while others required significant effort to grasp.
The insights I gained were invaluable, with certain lessons learned before taking on supervisory roles and others acquired through difficult experiences. All these lessons contributed to enhancing my supervisory abilities and fostering better workplace environments.
Section 1.1: Lessons Learned and Those I Wish I Had Known
In my journey, I've worked with both full-time and part-time staff, and I've found that my approach needed to adapt accordingly. In the workplace, employee selection can be influenced by budgetary constraints and institutional priorities.
Subsection 1.1.1: Recognizing Personal Biases
Throughout my career, I've had to confront my biases, particularly from a social justice perspective. Initially, I was responsible for diversity training without any direct reports. However, once I began supervising, it became essential to analyze how my privileged identities influenced my interactions at work.
While I could easily identify instances of macro and micro-aggressions aimed at me, examining my identity as a cisgender male with advanced degrees was more challenging. To create a positive work environment, I needed to recognize the biases rooted in my past experiences.
One pivotal moment involved a female staff member who expressed feeling marginalized in our discussions. This experience compelled me to acknowledge my biases and realize that my intentions did not always align with the impact of my actions.
Section 1.2: The Dangers of Being Dismissive
I've often wished to emulate the fictional character Miranda Priestly from The Devil Wears Prada, known for her sharp remarks. However, adopting a villainous persona is counterproductive in a professional setting. My attempts to dominate conversations often resulted in confusion rather than clarity.
I discovered that fostering a collaborative atmosphere is far more beneficial than acting like an intimidating figure. Building relationships based on vulnerability and active listening proved essential for effective supervision.
Chapter 2: Anticipating Challenges and Problem Solving
The video "Providing Effective Supervision to Maintain Quality Employees" delves into the nuances of supervising staff and the importance of creating a supportive environment. In it, viewers can learn strategies to enhance their supervisory skills.
Section 2.1: Quick Decision-Making Strategies
My experience supervising part-time professionals while managing fraternity operations highlighted the need for rapid decision-making. Operating across different states, we often faced situations that required immediate communication to resolve issues.
Using video calls instead of emails allowed us to convey crucial information more effectively, fostering a quicker response to urgent matters. This proactive approach not only benefited us but also set a precedent for our chapters.
Subsection 2.1.1: Providing Supportive Structures
It's vital for supervisors to facilitate the learning of new skills among their staff. Implementing a structured approach, or "scaffolding," enables employees to distinguish between essential job skills and those that promote personal growth.
When introducing new concepts, such as budgeting or program evaluation, supervisors should offer support and guidance. Without this scaffolding, employees may struggle to apply their knowledge effectively.
Chapter 3: Evolving Relationship Dynamics
In the video "5 Tips for New Supervisors: What I Wish I Knew," essential advice is shared for navigating the complexities of supervision. It emphasizes understanding relationship dynamics and adapting one's approach to fit different situations.
Conclusion: Supporting Mid-Level Professionals
With nearly a decade of experience coaching entry-level and mid-level professionals, I am committed to helping others identify their strengths and develop new skills. If you're looking for guidance on navigating supervisory challenges, feel free to reach out for a consultation.
Joseph has transitioned from a 20-year career in higher education administration to non-profit workforce development, specializing in diversity, equity, and inclusion education, professional development, training, and leadership. He authored Tales of a Displaced Worker and The SAGA Facilitation Model.