Enraged Professionals Criticize The Bookseller's Anti-Trans Promotion
Written on
Chapter 1: The Controversy Unfolds
The Bookseller, a magazine dedicated to the publishing industry and owned by The Stage Media Company Ltd, is facing backlash for endorsing anti-trans social media accounts on its platform. An article titled "Publishing network launches for those 'concerned about the impact of gender ideology'" briefly discusses two "SEENPublishing" social media accounts but fails to provide any substantive information regarding their operators, objectives, or significance. The mere existence of these accounts does not constitute newsworthy content.
For those unfamiliar, "SEEN" represents individuals attempting to ideologically influence institutions through transphobic means. They are essentially a collection of bigots working together to perpetuate transphobia, often functioning as informal groups on platforms like WhatsApp.
As of now, the Twitter post promoting this article has garnered over 600 retweets and 300 comments, the vast majority of which voice strong disapproval of The Bookseller's support for these anti-trans accounts. This sentiment is echoed by numerous industry professionals, including notable figures such as [insert names], and many others.
Publishing organizations have also expressed their concerns, with official statements from [insert organizations], as well as from Headwater Literary Management.
Numerous transgender professionals within the industry have voiced their disappointment regarding The Bookseller's actions, including [insert names]. Clearly, the industry is not pleased with The Bookseller's stance on promoting these accounts. I attempted to reach out to The Bookseller for clarification via Twitter, initially tagging the article's author, Lauren Brown.
Subsequently, the post was altered to reflect "The Bookseller Editorial Team." I observed that Lauren Brown utilized Twitter's "leave this conversation" feature to untag herself from my inquiry about her decision to write this piece. Despite knowing she saw my message, she opted to ignore it, eventually blocking me for seeking clarification.
I then tried to email Heloise Wood, a deputy news editor at The Bookseller, sharing a screenshot of my correspondence. Unfortunately, I received no response through either email or Twitter, until I noticed she began following me, indicating she had viewed my profile.
This pattern suggests a deliberate choice to overlook my request for insights into why The Bookseller opted to promote anti-trans accounts, especially during Pride Month. The intentionality behind this decision leads me to believe they were aware of their misstep prior to publication. They likely anticipated increased traffic from both anti-trans and pro-trans individuals curious about the article, banking on a quick shift in focus from the community.
It is vital that industry professionals do not allow this situation to fade away, and I believe they won't. Conversations with individuals connected to The Bookseller reveal a shared disgust regarding the article's content. Many are seizing this moment to advocate for greater trans inclusion in publishing.
It is disheartening to see a respected entity like The Bookseller engage in such low-level outrage-seeking behavior, especially when they lack the courage to defend their actions in the face of widespread criticism. However, it has been inspiring to witness the industry rally around trans inclusion in publishing.
Ironically, the backlash against The Bookseller for endorsing anti-trans accounts is far more newsworthy than the accounts themselves could ever aspire to be. Yet, we all know that The Bookseller is unlikely to cover this story, as it would require them to acknowledge a mistake or reaffirm their misjudgment, risking further backlash.
This scenario is akin to sabotaging your own meal to deter others from eating it; all it achieves is rendering your own lunch inedible while potentially forcing you to reconsider consuming something unpleasant.
Additionally, don't miss our commissioned works by trans authors, including Andrew Joseph White's pieces and Harry Nicholas's contributions. Also, take a look at Kestral Gaian's book about Section 28 and her writing for The Prince.
Instead of promoting bigots, why not celebrate the beautiful and incredible art being created in our community?
Chapter 2: The Community Response
The first video explores the outrage surrounding anti-trans narratives and features discussions from LGBT YouTubers who are advocating for change and inclusivity in the industry.
In the second video, J.K. Rowling addresses her previous anti-trans statements, providing a critical examination of her arguments and their implications for the community.