Rethinking Network Effects: A New Perspective on Metcalfe's Law
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Network Effects
When you step into a gathering of investors and innovators, the term "network effect" is likely to echo throughout the room. It's a buzzword that seems omnipresent.
Photo by Saad Ahmad on Unsplash
Network effects are often heralded as the ultimate competitive advantage in business. If asked to identify a singular key to success, many might enthusiastically point to the power of network effects. This is why many incubators and venture capitalists focus exclusively on businesses that can harness these effects, and it's easy to understand their reasoning.
The concept of network effects is frequently illustrated by Metcalfe’s Law, which posits that adding an additional node to a network significantly boosts its value. Rather than simply adding up (5+5=10), the value expands in a non-linear fashion—potentially reaching something closer to 20.
For instance, consider Facebook: its worth to you increased as more of your friends joined the platform.
The internet enables networks to scale in seemingly infinite ways. Coupled with our natural optimism, one might argue that Metcalfe’s Law applies universally across various sectors—from homeowners to pet food and software solutions. However, what if our understanding of this empirical observation is fundamentally flawed?
Section 1.1: A Different Perspective
Take into account Ziph's Law, which is foundational to the concept of the Long Tail. This principle suggests that the value of the first place is K, while the second is worth 1/K—indicating that each subsequent addition to the network is progressively less valuable (think of the 80/20 rule in sales of books, songs, and films).
Ziph's Law illustrates why e-commerce thrives in niche markets. It explains how Amazon's vast online catalog surpassed the constraints of physical stores, enabling it to cater to every niche audience overlooked by traditional retailers.
The value of the thousandth item isn't zero; rather, brick-and-mortar stores cannot justify the cost of stocking niche products. In contrast, online platforms incur minimal inventory costs, allowing them to showcase a broader array of items.
Section 1.2: Reassessing Metcalfe’s Law
Metcalfe's Law operates under the assumption that each new addition to a network exponentially increases its value (with value potentially quadrupling with each doubling). However, we must question whether all networks bear equal significance.
In our lives, we navigate both weak and strong networks, and the same applies to communities. Not all connections created on platforms like Facebook are equally valuable. The initial 20-50 connections may hold the bulk of the network's worth, while the value of subsequent connections diminishes.
This diminishing return is emphasized by Ziph's Law. Yet, many overlook this reality when assessing tech companies, erroneously believing they are destined for massive success due to Metcalfe’s Law. There is always a ceiling to a network's potential value.
If each new connection in my life follows a logarithmic growth pattern rather than exponential, wouldn’t this apply to the larger platform as well? Each network varies in size and diminishes differently.
Chapter 2: The Limits of Growth
Metcalfe initially employed his law to illustrate a threshold at which a network could become sustainable. However, once this threshold is crossed, it may be unrealistic to expect growth to continue in a straight line upward. Instead, it is more prudent to anticipate a trend that resembles an S-curve.
All good things eventually taper off, and that’s part of their charm. While some may endure longer than others, it’s essential to recognize that we often assume too many will sustain for an extended period.
The first video titled "Metcalf's Law in Network Economics" explores the implications of network effects in various industries, providing a deeper understanding of how they shape business dynamics.
The second video "Metcalfe's Law: Network Effect" delves into the concept of network effects, illustrating its significance in the modern economy and its impact on technology companies.