A Disappointing Take on War of the Worlds: The Attack (2023)
Written on
Chapter 1 Overview
The recent adaptation of War of the Worlds: The Attack (2023) has generated buzz, but it seems to cater only to the most devoted fans of H.G. Wells. Despite its unique CGI representations of Martians and their menacing technology, the film ultimately disappoints with its weak plot and character development. Therefore, I would rate it a modest 2 out of 5 stars.
While I suggest giving this film, available on AppleTV+ via Vertical Entertainment, a watch, it’s crucial to approach it with tempered expectations. The film’s budget constraints are evident, leading to a lackluster narrative that is difficult to engage with.
Section 1.1 CGI Visuals and Alien Representation
One notable aspect of this version is its portrayal of alien tripods, which can be destroyed using conventional weapons—a departure from other adaptations where they were shielded against such attacks. For instance, in the Spielberg/Cruise version, the only way to defeat them was through sabotage while on board. This unique element offers a fresh perspective, albeit within an otherwise disappointing framework.
Section 1.2 Narrative and Character Flaws
The film falters in key areas such as writing, character development, and overall coherence. The script seems more focused on distracting subplots and preachy themes rather than the captivating alien invasion narrative. Consequently, moments of genuine intrigue are fleeting.
The characters—three PhD students—feel underdeveloped and uninteresting. Their interactions lack the depth and excitement one might expect from aspiring astrophysicists facing an alien crisis. Instead of experiencing any sense of wonder or urgency, viewers are left feeling detached from the unfolding chaos.
Chapter 2 Production Quality
While the CGI and design of the aliens are commendable, the initial appearance of an alien falls flat due to poor execution. The special effects are a silver lining in an otherwise lackluster production.
Section 2.1 Weak Screenplay and Direction
The dialogue is painfully uninspired, and the focus veers away from the sci-fi elements that should take precedence. The film is cluttered with trivial human drama that overwhelms the central plot. Additionally, the film's critique of masculinity, religion, and military themes feels forced and detracts from the overall experience.
Section 2.2 Casting Choices
The casting choices further contribute to the film's shortcomings. The female lead manages to hold the narrative together to an extent, but the male characters are depicted as weak or unlikable. This lack of engaging personalities hampers the film's ability to resonate with viewers.
In summary, while there are a few redeeming elements worth noting, this adaptation ultimately leaves much to be desired. As a fan of H.G. Wells, I am left yearning for a more faithful and dynamic interpretation of his timeless classic.