Rethinking Human Superiority: A New Perspective on Sentience
Written on
Chapter 1: A Shift in Understanding
Recent research increasingly indicates that other animals share far more similarities with humans than we previously thought, prompting a re-evaluation of what it means to be human.
For centuries, particularly in the last few hundred years, humans have considered themselves the pinnacle of evolution. This perspective has led many, especially in Western cultures, to view ourselves as distinct from the animal kingdom and the natural world. We have often perceived Nature as a resource to be exploited, believing that the entire planet exists for our benefit.
However, as we confront escalating climate crises and delve deeper into animal behavior research, it becomes evident that we are not separate from Nature; rather, we are an integral part of it. The belief in human superiority is increasingly being challenged by scientific discoveries suggesting that our species, Homo sapiens, may not be as unique as we once assumed.
Section 1.1: Historical Context
The trajectory of human development has contributed to our inflated sense of superiority. From technological advancements to urban living, it’s easy to see why we might feel exceptional. Yet, before our rise, humanity thrived in harmony with Nature for hundreds of thousands of years—longer still if we include our pre-Homo sapiens ancestors. Then, for reasons still debated, we broke this harmonious cycle and embarked on a path of self-discovery.
We developed methods to transmit knowledge across generations through language and storytelling. We mastered agriculture, mathematics, and construction. Over time, we shifted our understanding of the planet from a shared habitat to one that we dominate.
The 17th-century philosopher René Descartes famously suggested that animals lack souls, reinforcing the human-centric worldview. According to Stanford’s Philosophical Encyclopedia, Descartes viewed nonhuman animals as mere automatons devoid of consciousness, attributing their behaviors to instinct rather than sentience. This perspective has led to tragic consequences in the treatment of animals, a topic I will not delve into here as it detracts from the main focus.
Fortunately, we are gradually moving away from this outdated view. Interacting with pets or observing animal behavior reveals their capacity for emotions, a fact supported by a wealth of scientific research that contradicts long-held beliefs.
Subsection 1.1.1: Evidence of Sentience
The first video, "Bioremediating Greenness - Rethinking Human Exceptionalism," by Adam Brown, delves into how our understanding of sentience is evolving and challenges the notion of human exceptionalism.
Section 1.2: Recent Developments
In modern history, our focus has largely been on exploring the external world through agriculture, architecture, and technological advancements. While we've made remarkable strides, there is a growing shift towards introspection.
As we strive to decode our dreams and comprehend our emotions, we are rediscovering the wisdom of our ancestors who recognized that we are not the only conscious beings on this planet. Scientific exploration often begins with animal testing, which, despite ethical debates, has unveiled the emotional complexity and consciousness present in various species.
It’s noteworthy that, as of January 2023, the U.S. Federal Drug Administration (FDA) has removed the requirement for animal testing prior to clinical trials, signifying a shift in ethical considerations.
Chapter 2: The Legacy of Our Ancestors
The second video, "The Difficult Task of Identifying Human Exceptionalism," discusses the challenges in recognizing the shared traits between humans and animals.
The exploration of our human ancestry reveals that many traits we value may not be unique to us. For instance, the Neanderthals, our close relatives, demonstrated behaviors such as burying their dead and creating tools. Archaeological findings, including those of Homo naledi, suggest that these practices predate our existence.
The evidence shows that we may not have invented many of the attributes we take pride in but rather inherited them through shared experiences with other hominin species.
Non-Human Sentience
While pet owners may intuitively recognize animal emotions, scientific research supports this observation across various species, including primates, elephants, and even insects. The work of experts like Marc Bekoff highlights the extensive evidence of animal sentience, suggesting that many species experience a range of emotions and social behaviors.
Recent studies show that sentience is not limited to mammals; even fish and insects exhibit complex behaviors, challenging the notion that emotional capabilities are unique to higher vertebrates. Research has uncovered that animals engage in social learning, display empathy, and even experience stress.
As we continue to expand our understanding of consciousness, we find that many animals possess the neurological structures necessary for emotional processing, as affirmed by the 2012 "Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness."
Insects, often overlooked, also demonstrate sentience—spiders can dream, and bumblebees engage in play, indicating a depth of experience previously unacknowledged.
Perspective Shift
While humans are the last surviving members of our genus, and no other species has achieved the same level of global influence, it’s essential to consider our perspective. Perhaps other animals refrained from pursuing certain paths because they understood the potential consequences better than we do.
What we perceive as unique human traits—such as community-building, emotional connection, and a desire for safety—are evident across the animal kingdom. As Bekoff states, the traits we possess are not exclusive; they are shared across species.
This realization compels us to reevaluate our understanding of what it means to be human. As the evidence of animal sentience mounts, it is crucial to acknowledge our similarities and redefine our relationships with other species.
For further insights, subscribe to Katrina’s newsletter, Curious Adventure, to receive her articles directly in your inbox every Friday and Monday morning!